Last Updated on February 9, 2022 by Jella Erhard
Explore the best true crime candles that can also make killer true crime gifts. The most brilliant unique candles for the true crime fans in your life.
PIN ME for later
Can’t get enough of true crime? We got you. You’ll find here some of the most fun and unique true crime candles that will be your favorite things to light up during your fav true crime show or when you read your spooky true crime novels.
These brilliant candles are also great budget unique gift ideas for true crime fans and horror lovers. No matter if you like minimalist, vintage, or unique vibes you’ll find here a candle that will steal your heart.
RELATED: Unique Gifts For Book Lovers
We also included some long-lasting true crime candles to make sure you can enjoy your new fav true crime merch for a long long time. It’s also one more reason why these candles make such great true crime gifts.
These candles are not only great decor items but can also boost your creativity and inspire you to try one of the many fun creative hobbies. There are amazing beginner-friendly candle making kits that will help you get started with this relaxing and fun hobby and you can even turn it into a side hustle once you get better at it.
19| Lizzie Borden Soy Candle
Lizzie Borden is widely known and the mystery around her is just fascinating. This simple, yet very stylish candle is a superb choice for everyone who loves that story. The apple maple bourbon scent is truly relaxing.
Get ready for your next true crime show with this Lizzie Borden-inspired true crime candle.
18| Talk Murder to Me Candle
Sometimes the simpler is the better. You can say a lot with just a few words and this candle tells everything about all murderino. When someone asks you to talk murder to them, you know what kind of person they are. The murderino kind, who cannot have enough true crimes.
Talk Murder To Me is a really fun and romantic True Crime Candle idea for fans.
17| True Crime Time
Another one of the creative true crime gifts is this fun and beautiful candle. It also sends a message to the rest of the household; if this candle is lit, you shall not be disturbed. When your favorite true crime show or movie is on, everyone is going to know to leave you alone.
If you’re looking for a really uniquely designed true crime candle then check out this beauty.
16| No Body, No Crime – True Crime Candle
Speaking of useful advice for murderers, the ‘no body, no crime’ approach seems to be very successful. This, “true crime” scented candle is definitely going to be the best company for your next evening in with a movie or book.
These fun true crime candles come in two sizes, 4 or 8 ounces. The bigger one can burn for up to 50 hours.
15| True Crime Candle / Murder Mystery Candle
Some of the coolest true crime candles are just scary as witty. These coconut candles are all vegan and cruelty-free, so you can enjoy your unique candles for true crime lovers without any second thought. The label is on point, every murderino is going to love it. The candles burn for over 55 hours.
This bloody good true crime candle is another long-lasting beauty any true crime fan would be happy to have.
14| BURN the EVIDENCE True Crime Lover Candle
Have you been wondering how to get away with murder? We really hope you are not considering, but here is a tip: burn the evidence. This true crime candle looks great in every setting, while also has some wisdom to share.
You can order three different scents: comfort spice, sea breeze, and vanilla bean.
13| True Crime & Murder Mystery Inspired Soy Candle
Once taking off the lid of this candle, you are going to find yourself at a crime scene. A cleaver covered in blood is the sign of another fun night watching true crime dramas. Light the candle and get a relaxing mixture to fill your room.
The scent is a blend of citrus and saffron with notes of violet and amber finished with smokey sandalwood. It can burn for over 50 hours.
If you’re looking for unique and long-lasting true crime candles then you should go with this one.
12| Lizzie Borden “Bleeding” Candle
Here is another one of the unique candles for true crime lovers. If you are a top to bottom murderino, we are sure you know Lizzie Borden’s story. If you are not familiar with how she was tried for the axe murder of her father, this candle may be less funny for you.
What makes it even more unique is the smell. It is a mixture of axe handle, tool shed, a little pipe smoke and rose perfume, so you can feel like being in the room on that famous day.
Furthermore, as this spooky true crime candle burns, the axe at the top begins to bleed.
11| True Crime Junkie
Most murderino know it is always the husband that has to be looked into. Whenever you see a murdered person, the first suspect that comes to mind is the husband for sure. This candle intends to remind everyone of that.
These cool true crime candles come in three fun scents, comfort spice, sea breeze, and vanilla bean.
10| Congrats on the new house, hope your neighbors aren’t serial killers
If you are looking for true crime housewarming gifts, this candle is definitely a great choice. When offering a gift that is useful and comes with a good wish is the main goal. What would be a better wish than hoping for no serial killer neighbors?
These true crime candles come in a number of amazing scents, over 20 options for you so there is definitely something for the person you are surprising.
9| Netflix And Kill Infused With A True Crime Junkie | Premium Soy True Crime Candles
If you are looking for unique candles for true crime lovers, this Netflix and Kill scented candle is perfect. On the most popular streaming site, you can find some of the most popular and twisted true crime shows based on real events.
There are four different scents, each of them is a really exciting combination. If you are looking for true crime gifts for men or women, pick the right scent and you are good to go. There is hazelnut and coffee, apple and maple bourbon, pumpkin and creme brulee, and spiced honey and tonka. You cannot go wrong with either of them.
These true crime candles come in three sizes, the biggest one can burn for up to 98 hours.
8| Cereal Killer Candle / Serial Killer Candle
A good pun always goes a long way. This fun cereal killer candle is definitely going to be a conversation maker at every gathering. If your friends like true crime or horrors, this one would be a great gift. It comes in two sizes four and eight ounces. We are certain all fruit loops lovers would be happy with this fantastic gift.
If you’re looking for fun & crunchy True Crime candles you should go with this one.
7| Murderino True Crime Candles – Stay Sexy and Don’t Get Murdered
If you are a true murderino, this one is definitely going to be one of your favorite true crime candles. SSDGM is a pretty good mentality, so take the advice. It could be a great gift for everyone, who loves the true crime genre.
The hand-poured, forest-scented candle can burn for approximately 50 hours, so it will be good company while listening to podcasts or reading a good book. The candle is thoughtfully packed in a box making it a perfect gift for valentine’s day or other special occasions. Overall, it is a great addition to every murderino’s reading or podcasting nook.
6| True Crime and Chill – Soy True Crime Candle
The two might sound contradictory as true crime doesn’t always sound too relaxing. However, all fans know how great it is to sit back and enjoy a true crime read or podcast. This beautiful and cool candle is a truly amazing decoration in every home, where murder is part of the everyday.
A few drops of blood and a pleasant scent can help all true crime fans get into the mood. Once you light it, vanilla sugar, soft musk, and sweet apple will relax your mind and set you up for another mind-blowing true story of murder.
If you are looking for true crime gifts that will make someone’s day, you cannot go wrong with this one.
5| True Crimes & Chill – Handmade Soy True Crime Candles
This seller on Etsy has some of the best unique candles for true crime lovers. Their candles are “infused with suspense” so you can rest assured it will be a truly amazing experience. They mean True Crimes and Chill for sure, as their candles come in over twenty different scents including the usual relaxing citronella, grass, jasmine, or clean laundry.
On top of that, you can pick from some of the more unusual ones such as s’mores, firewood, and smoke, or the perfect pick for a movie night, popcorn.
There is no doubt, if you are looking for true crime gifts, you can definitely find a suitable scent for everyone.
4| Serial Killer Repellent Aromatherapy Candles
There is no more important item than an effective serial killer repellent when watching a movie like Friday the 13th. However, true crime lovers may find it even more useful. No one would want a real-life serial killer lurking around their home, so make sure to light this candle every once in a while.
The candles come in three different scents, comfort spice, sea breeze, and vanilla bean. These lovable scents will hopefully repel all murderers. It is certainly one of the most fun gifts for true crime lovers.
These multi-color funny true crime candles not only have a great smell but they will certainly look cool in all homes.
3| Shiplap, Wine, & True Crime – Hand Poured Soy Candle
Sometimes simple ones are the most unique candles for true crime lovers. The packaging is delightfully neat and somehow still warm that making people want to keep it on the shelf in their true crime nook. The rustic look comes with rustic scents, shiplap, wine, and amber ensuring a truly fun time in a mindset for whatever may come.
The hand-poured soy candles are shipped from Maine and are delightfully clear. Each candle is 9oz and all-natural, so you do not have to worry about all sorts of unhealthy additions.
You and all your true crime lover friends and loved ones are going to love these rich Egyptian Amber-infused candles for sure.
2| Stay Sexy – Fun True Crime Candle
Another one of the fun and decorative true candles that encourages you to stay sexy and don’t get murdered. We are certainly all for not getting murdered. The candle is superbly decorative, everyone would love it in their home for sure.
The scent is actually really interesting; wet earth and roses create a “secret grave” vibe in your home. It will give you the feeling of sitting in a graveyard or hiding from the murderer in a secret grave. The 100% soy candles can burn for around fifty hours.
It is among the most unique candles for true crime lovers so don’t hesitate to surprise your other half or friends with one at the next valentine’s day or special occasion.
1| Introverted But Willing to discuss True Crime – Funny True Crime Candle
This fun and exciting candle is certainly among the best true crime gifts. All introverted murderino is going to find it a superb gift for sure. Another reason it is a great surprise, the lid can be personalized, so your friends or partner will know you were thinking of them. You can order a smaller one, and a mason jar-sized candle, which may burn for a really good time.
Furthermore, the candles come in over thirty scents, which is a really huge variety to choose from. Besides the unique scents like peppermint brownie, cedar tobacco, and cinna bomb, you can find more traditional ones such as lavender vanilla or freshly cut Xmas tree.
This fun and heavenly scented true crime candle is a perfect choice for introverts.
PIN ME for later
THANK YOU FOR READING!