Explore the best murder mystery party games for adults. Play with some of the most thrilling murder mystery games and subscriptions and host the spookiest mystery game night of your life.
PIN me for later
Thrilling Murder Mystery Party Games Adults Will Love
* Disclaimer: Some links on AsianaCircus.com are affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase we may receive a small commission (at no additional cost to you).
One of the best ways to make any dinner party or game night instantly spookier is by playing a thrilling murder mystery party game. Take your love of mystery, true crime, and detective shows to the next level with these fun and challenging mystery games.
Some of these murder mystery games are only for adults so make sure to check the description and props before you let kids or teens take part in the game. However, you’ll find plenty of fun and more chill murder mystery games on our list that can be played by younger mystery lovers as well.
If you love hosting game nights and looking for fun game night ideas for adults you should check out our other posts as well.
Are you looking for spooky and fun murder mystery games for Halloween parties that adults will love too? You’re at the right place. Some of these games will give you goosebumps and make your heart beat faster as you try to solve some of the scariest murder cases ever.
In case you’re a hardcore murder mystery game lover you should also check out the amazing murder mystery subscription boxes added to the list that’ll easily feed your mystery cravings for many months to come.
You can also consider going all in and throw a themed party that goes well with your chosen game and even serve some unique game night snacks to make your murder mystery party unforgettable.
25| An Invitation to Midnight Manor – Murder Mystery Party
Midnight Manor is a spooky at-home murder mystery party game for adults you can get in a full box kit version or a downloadable PDF version. It’s a highly interactive murder mystery game for a minimum of 10 and a maximum of 20 players. It’s also pretty great since the game has 8 female, 8 male, and 4 gender-neutral character options.
In case you’re hosting a larger game night you can get their extension that’s perfect for 21 to 30 players. The story is about a mysterious stranger who moves into a manor with a horrible past and you and your guests have to find out who committed the murder.
24| The Cinderella Murders: Fairy Tale Files Game and Murder Mystery Game
This super fun and whimsical murder mystery game is perfect for fairy tale and Disney fans. It’s the game that mixes happily ever after with true crime and creates a unique, and truly entertaining game for all ages. This beautiful game can be played by 1 to 4 players and from the age of 12. While it’s not going to be the hardest murder mystery case you’ll ever solve it’ll surely be one of the most memorable ones.
You’ll get all the props you need for the game including suspect cards, adventure cards, a crime scene, The Fairyland Chronicles newspapers, and many more including an online messaging system. The players will have to solve the murder of Lady Treville and one of her daughters after they were found stabbed to death in the royal gardens by a glass slipper. You will have to join the Magical Mishaps Agency to find out if it was really Cinderella who committed the crime.
23| Wizard World Murder Mystery Party Game
Wizard World is another magical murder mystery party game for fantasy and of course Harry Potter lovers. It’s a fun game for ages 14 and up and it is for 8 players (they also have a 10 players version available). It’s a printable murder mystery game so you’ll have to use your DIY skills just a little but for the price, it’s more than worth it. If you’re into role-playing then get your capes ready because this is the perfect role play murder mystery game for you.
You’ll get everything you need, you just have to print out the Instructions, player character books, and character invitations and get ready for a magic-filled murder mystery party. Players will have to gather in the dim candlelit study of the late Willie Wigglesworth for the reading of his will. Willie was brutally murdered three days ago and the players are the suspects. Whoever discovers the murderer can claim Willie’s vast fortune. However, if players are not careful enough they can end up in Azkaban.
22| Horror on the Haunted House Tour, Halloween-Themed Murder Mystery Party Game
Horror on The Haunted House Tour is one of the best Halloween party games you can go for. It’s a truly spooky game for ages 13 and up and for players 4 to 20. You’ll get a digital download and just print out all the props you need. You can play the game as many times as you like you’ll just have to assign secretly a new killer every time.
One of the most special things about this game is that you can request the game makers to host the party for you. You just have to sign up for their Hosting Concierge Service. Players will be tourists who are signed up for a Halloween night ghost tour. However, things turn serious when the tour group suddenly finds the dead body of the Tour Guide in one of the houses. Now it’s the team’s task to find out who killed her and why.
21| Hunt A Killer Death at The Dive Bar, Immersive Murder Mystery Game
Hunt A Killer is one of the most popular murder mystery party games and it has been shipped to over 2 million murder mystery fans all over the world. It’s an immersive investigation during which players can feel as if they’re solving a real-life murder mystery. While it’s a great mystery game for parties or game nights it’s also a good option for solo players since it can be played by 1 to 5 players for ages 14 and up.
20| Hunt A Killer The Moon Summit Mystery Complete Box Set Special Edition, Murder Mystery Game
Hunt A Killer‘s complete box set is another popular murder mystery game that has been shipped to over 2 million murder mystery fans who crave 10+ hours of thrilling gameplay. The box set contains 6 boxes in one that can be played by 1 to 6 players and ages 14 and up. Players will have to decipher codes and solve puzzles to understand the true motives of the suspects.
You’ll have to find out the truth about Toby Mendia’s mysterious death that was simply blamed on local wildlife. Now players have to help private investigator Michelle Gray to find out what really happened in Moon Summit Park, Alaska.
19| Murder Mystery Party Games – Murder At Mardi Gras
Murder at Mardi Gras is a fun-filled murder mystery game for those who are looking for a bit more lighthearted mystery game. It’s for 8 players and for ages 18 and over however, you can be an absolute murder mystery beginner and you’ll still enjoy this game. It’s a great choice for Halloween or costume parties and you can even play the audio and video introduction to make the event more special.
Players will have to find out what happened to Pierre DuPre who was found strangled by a pair of Mardi Gras beads. Now it’s your job to find the murderer before they strike again. If you want to host a New Orleans-themed game night this is a great choice, after the game you can also watch some of the best movies set in New Orleans to make the night even more special.
18| UNSOLVED CASE FILES: Cold Case Murder Mystery Game: Who Murdered Harmony Ashcroft?
Unsolved Case Files is a really fun murder mystery game that lets you become a cold case detective. Players have to solve murders that happened decades ago with only the original investigator’s case file.
It’s one of the few murder mystery games that can be played solo but it’s also a thrilling game night idea for couples and groups too from ages 13 and up. Players will have to solve 3 mysteries to crack the case with the help of their investigative skills and over 50 investigation documents and photos.
17| Mysterium Board Game – Mystery Board Game For Adults
Mysterium board game is for those who prefer spooky fun over real crime. This game can be played by two to 7 players from the age of 10. Players will have to find out who committed the horrible crime on the grounds of the Warwick Manor thirty years ago. One player will be the ghost who haunts the Manor and the other players will be the group of psychic investigators who have to get to the bottom of the mystery.
The game also has a high variability since there are dozens of different suspects, weapons, and locations to ensure no two games are ever the same. So, if you’re looking for spooky camping games for adults to take on your next trip you should pack this easily portable and super entertaining game for sure.
16| Murder on a Train – Murder Mystery Flexi-Party Dinner Party Game
Are you in love with movies and books set on trains? Then you should choose Murder On A Train murder mystery party game for adults. You’ll need 6 to 14 players for this game from ages 18 and the gameplay is about 2 to 3 hours.
Players will be transported back to the coldest month of 1933 near the Austrian border where passengers aboard the Simpleton-Orient Express experience, a murder and have to figure out who killed a mysterious stranger. You’ll get a re-usable white storage box, host guide, whodunit slips, character sheets, and everything else you’ll need to host a traditional seated murder mystery dinner party game.
15| Killer Trivia Game – The Best Murder Mystery Party Game
The Killer Trivia Game centers around murders, serial killers, famous celebrity scandals and deaths, as well as lots of strange and crazy deaths throughout history. You’ll need 2 to 12 players from ages 13 and up. It’s a really fun trivia-style murder mystery party game where answering questions may not be enough.
Players will have to use a fun courtroom scoring setting that leads to objections, cross-examinations, redirects, hung juries, and more, resulting in surprising lead changes and a whole lot of fun.
14| Bullets on Broadway Murder Mystery Party Game
Bullets on Broadway is not just for Broadway fans but they’re probably the ones who can fully appreciate this creative murder mystery game. It can be played with 4 to 20 people both virtually or in-person and from ages 18 plus.
It’s a multi-play game with a combination of 20 characters and three rounds of evidence where suspects have innocent and guilty stories to make the mystery even more exciting. You’ll also get downloadable files so you can print props at home and play multiple times any time you like.
13| Talking Tables Reusable Murder Mystery Game Kit
Murder Mystery at The Theatre is a perfect choice if you want to host an elegant Roaring 20s murder mystery party. Players will have to solve the mysterious murder that happened in the theatre. It’s a replayable game with 3 alternative endings.
You’ll need at least 5 to 13 players from ages 16 and up. You’ll get a beautifully made instruction booklet, a welcome speech, place cards, name cards, trait cards, murder weapon props among many other items, clues, and props that’ll make your themed party even more special.
YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE: Thrilling Escape Room Kits For Adults
12| Deception: Murder in Hong Kong Board Game, Fast Pace Murder Mystery Game
Deception: Murder in Hong Kong board game is perfect for those who love catching liars and think they would be able to get away with murder. You’ll need 4 to 12 players from ages 14 and up. One player will be the murderer who secretly chose to leave their weapon and the evidence behind. Another player will be the forensic scientist, and the rest are investigators, interpreting the clues to solve the murder and find out who is the murderer.
The game comes with role cards, clue cards, means cards, among many other intriguing and fun props. The murderer will have to try and confuse the detectives in order to get away with the murder.
11| Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective – Carlton House & Queen’s Park Board Game Murder Mystery Game For Adults
Sherlock Homes games are some of the most beloved classic murder mystery party games of all time. No matter if you love the new show, the old ones or if you read the books you’ll love this new standalone mystery game that will let you roam the streets of Victorian London looking for a murderer.
Carlton House & Queen’s Park introduces ten exciting cases that will draw players deep into the world of Sherlock Holmes. You’ll have to interview suspects, searching newspapers, and walking the streets for clues, and compare your detective skills to solve the mystery.
These cases are longest and more difficult so best for players ages 14 and older and for 1 to 8 players. and with an average playtime of about 90 minutes.
10| Expedition of Death – Murder Mystery Game For Adults
Expedition of Death is one of the most exciting murder mystery games set deep in the Peruvian Rainforest. After two months of archeological expedition, there is a celebration however, at midnight someone finds Archaeology professor Mary Stonerock’s murdered body. Players have to figure out who is the murderer. It’s suitable for players ages 18 and up and for 5 to 7 players. Character booklets, name tags, and everything else are included to host an epic murder mystery game night.
9| Murder Mystery on The Dancefloor – Murder Mystery Party Game
Murder Mystery On The Dance Floor is about a murder at Boogieland 77, the glitziest club in New York. Players, of course, have to find out who done it. It’s best for players aged 16 and up and with 5 to 13 players. This game is also replayable since it has 3 alternative endings. You’ll get an instruction booklet, welcome speech, place cards, name cards, trait cards, and everything else to host an epic game night.
8| Hunt A Killer Nancy Drew – Mystery at Magnolia Gardens, Immersive Murder Mystery Game
Mystery At Magnolia Gardens is one of the most exciting Nancy Drew murder mystery games. Players will have to sort through testimonials, create timelines, and confirm alibis to crack the case. It can be played by players 14 years and up.
7| Murder at Blood Mansion Deluxe Card Game
Murder At Blood Mansion is an intense murder mystery card game for 2 to 9 players from ages 9 and up. It’s a spooky but family-friendly murder mystery game where players have to use their deduction and bluffing skills to find out who the murderer is. However, if you’re the murderer your job is to escape the Mansion without getting caught. You’ll get 76 beautiful tarot-sized cards, and 9 wooden character gear-shaped tokens.
It’s a simple but one of the most fun murder mystery party games for families.
6| Murder Mystery Game Lovely City, Independence Day Killer, Season 1 All 5 Episodes
Independence Day lets you become the detective and be entertained for countless hours. You’ll have to investigate a serial killer in the city of Lovely, Florida. Once a year, on Independence Day, a victim is found stabbed. Your job is to help the detectives catch the Independence Day Killer. All props, interviews, newspaper articles, crime scene drawings, and all kinds of other clues, and evidence are included to help you catch the killer.
The game can be played with 14 to 99 players and ages 14 and up. Independence Day is the murder mystery game for you if you want a really detailed mystery case with great props.
5| Paranormal Detectives – Murder Mystery Party Game
Paranormal Detectives is one of the most fun murder mystery party games. One of the players will have to take the role of a Ghost while the others work as paranormal detectives who need to discover how the victim died. The detectives can use their paranormal abilities to communicate with the ghost to find out what really happened. However, the ghost will only answer in ghostly ways like arranging a hangman’s knot, playing chosen Tarot cards, creating a word puzzle on a talking board, drawing by holding the hand of a detective, and many more fun ways. You’ll need 2 to 6 players aged 12 and up.
4| Deluxe 221B Baker Street Board Game – 200 Intriguing Adventures
This Deluxe 221B Baker Street Sherlock Holmes is one of the best mystery board games and is a perfect choice for those who love classic detective games. Players can enjoy 200 intriguing Sherlock Holmes adventures while traveling through the alleys of Victorian London picking up clues. The game can be played competitively by 2 or more individuals or teams for ages 14 and up. You’ll also get beautifully made props, a board, tokens, and all kinds of cards, booklets, and a checklist pad to make the gaming experience more exciting. If you’re looking for classic murder mystery party games you should try this one.
Murder Mystery Subscription Boxes
3| This Whodunit is KILLER – Murder Mystery Game Subscription Box
A Killing Affair games are just like watching your favorite murder mystery or crime TV show. You will start with Season 1, Episode 1, and all seasons are 5 episodes long. Each month, players will have to work through secret messages, hidden clues, and evidence, all while eliminating suspects. Once you have your final episode, you will have everything you need to convict the killer. It’s great for ages 12 and up and best played in small groups. You can cancel the subscription anytime you like and you’ll need internet access in order to be able to engage with the immersive online experience.
It’s one of the best murder mystery subscription boxes for those who love brain teasers and working on projects for a longer time.
2| CosyKiller: For the Armchair Sleuth – Murder Mystery Game Subscription Box
Cozy Killer is the murder mystery subscription box for you if you would love to solve cold cases. With this immersive murder mystery experience, you will get a complex world of puzzles, ciphers, suspects, and backstories – there’s even a few false leads to throw you off the trail. Each box is packed with vintage memorabilia, keepsakes…and intrigue. This game is best for teens and adults who are ready to make a commitment since 1 mystery will take 12 months (12 boxes) to complete.
1| The Deadbolt Mystery Society Monthly Murder Mystery Subscription Box
The Deadbolt Mystery Society is one of the most thrilling murder mystery subscription boxes where subscribers will receive a new stand-alone case file with everything needed to solve the mystery. Players can enjoy immersive scenarios, intriguing characters, and original compelling stories with their friends and family. Since each box is a new mystery and doesn’t require any additions you can start and stop each mystery at any time you like. You can play this game with up to 4 people and is best for players 13 years and older.
If you like to host murder mystery parties often, then this is one of the best murder mystery party games for you.
Thank you for Reading!