Last Updated on May 25, 2022 by Jella Erhard
Try the best murder mystery games for adults at your next mystery dinner party. Host the most epic and spookiest themed mystery party in your home with some of the most thrilling adult murder mystery games.
PIN ME for later
Spookiest Murder Mystery Games For Adults
* Disclaimer: Some links on AsianaCircus.com are affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase we may receive a small commission (at no additional cost to you).
Get ready for some of the spookiest and most fun game nights of your life. These scary good murder mystery games for adults will help you turn your murder mystery dinner parties into something truly special and memorable. We included some of the most unique and creepy mystery games that’ll surely challenge you and let you experience murder mystery games in a new way.
If you love themed parties then you’re also at the right place. Because these murder mystery games are not only entertaining but come with all kinds of props that’ll help you host the most fun-themed party you’ve ever hosted.
You’ll also find here scary adult murder mystery games that’ll challenge. Explore interactive and immersive party games for adults and new exciting game night ideas for adults, who love escape rooms and unique games.
We also included some vintage and classic games that will help you experience your favorite stories and childhood favorites in a whole new and spooky way.
11| Identity Games – Nightmare Horror Adventures
If you’re looking for a truly hair-raising and immersive scary murder mystery game for adults then check out Nightmare Horror Adventures. This is one of the spookiest murder mystery board games for adults with 4-5 players. If you love role-playing then you’ll love solving this gruesome murder mystery.
You’ll have to explore the creepy Crafton Mansion where you’ll have to solve the cold case of the horrific murder of your parents after 15 years. However, the danger is still present and you’ll not only have to solve the murder from your childhood but also prevent your own.
You’ll also get some pretty neet components that make the game even more enjoyable including 5 x blindfolds, 5 x pencils, 5 x notepads, and get access to interactive multimedia.
If you want to play with truly immersive and scary murder mystery games for adults then this creepy and fun game night idea is for you.
10| Pirate Murder Mystery Party Game
Are you into Pirates of the Caribbean? Then check out this really fun and spooky printable murder mystery dinner party game for 10 players. It’s perfect for game nights when you want something spooky you can play with larger groups.
You just have to download the materials and start playing. You’ll be one of ten crew members aboard the Sweet Revenge Pirate Ship. But your captain mysteriously gets murdered and you have to solve the case.
It’s a humorous and spooky murder mystery game for adults who love mysteries but don’t want to play with anything too gory. You’ll also get all kinds of cool printable PDF files to make your murder mystery game night better like unique guest invitations, game booklets and clues, pirate-style wine labels, menu tags, and even cool recipes and menus for both teenagers and adults.
If you’re looking for a fun and not too scary murder mystery game then check out this exciting pirates inspired game.
9| At Home Murder Mystery Game Box
Looking for a unique murder mystery box? Then Talking Tables’ Circus Murder Mystery Game is the right choice for you. Thanks to this brilliant at-home murder mystery box you’ll be able to easily host the most epic murder mystery game night and dinner party of your life.
You’ll have to solve the mystery of who killed Rollo Upp the ringmaster. This game comes with 3 alternative endings so you can enjoy multiple nights of interactive murder mystery fun in your own home.
You’ll also get all kinds of great stuff like beautiful invites, place cards, props, weapons, and clues that will help you transform your home into a circus crime scene.
If you’re looking for an immersive murder mystery game box for adults that will turn your home into a spooky circus then this game is for you.
8| Printable Murder at the Crimson Asylum – Adult Murder Mystery Detective Game
What’s more creepy and scary than an asylum? This easy-to-set-up printable murder mystery game is also an escape room which makes the experience much more enjoyable. If you’re into scary escape room games then you’ll love this asylum-themed one for sure.
This game is not only spooky but comes with plenty of amazingly spooky printable props including unique props and creepy room decor that’ll make your murder mystery night more memorable. It’s best for smaller groups since it’s for 5 players.
You’ll have to visit the Crimson asylum and solve the murder of Nicholas Harrison.
If you’re looking for scary printable murder mystery games for adults with an escape room twist then this asylum-themed game is for you.
7| An Invitation to Midnight Manor – Group Murder Mystery Party Game
Midnight Manor is one of the most popular murder mystery games for adults. The story is about a mysterious stranger who moves into a manor with a horrible past, what could possibly go wrong?
Midnight Manor has a superbly spooky atmosphere and is a highly interactive, at-home Murder Mystery Party game for adults who love big gatherings since this game can be played by 10-20 players.
You’ll be able to immediately download all the files, great tips and tricks for party hosts, detailed character cards, and invitations, in PDF and print them out whenever so it’s also a great last-minute game night idea that’ll surely entertain all the guests. If you’re planning ahead you can easily make your murder mystery dinner party even more special with their extras including award certificates for most in character, best acted out death, and closest guess, wine labels, party posters, voting cards, and action cards.
If you’re looking for an interactive murder mystery game for large groups that’ll help you host an epic murder mystery game night then Midnight Manor is for you.
6| Halloween Adult Murder Mystery Party Game
If you’re a fantasy lover then you’ll probably love this adult murder mystery game that can be played in person or over zoom. You’ll get a spooky monster murder mystery kit that will let you party at the Monster Mansion.
The players will be invited to Dracula’s birthday party but during the night Dracula is found with a stake in his chest. You’ll have to solve Drac’s murder and find out who is the real monster.
You’ll find all kinds of awesome printable props in this murder mystery kit including a host guide, game menu, character sheets, personalized murder mystery Invitations, cocktail recipes and a Spotify playlist to help set the atmosphere for your party.
If you love vampire stories and looking for scary murder mystery games for adults where you can hunt for monsters then this game is the right choice for you.
5| Independence Day Killer – Detective Murder Mystery Game
Do you love true crime and mystery shows on Netflix? Then this murder mystery game will blow your mind. It’s designed and has to be played like a season of Netflix. Each episode gives you tasks to complete and suspects to eliminate and carries forward to the next episode and in the final episode, you will convict your killer.
You’ll be a part of the detective team by joining A.K.A’s Criminal Investigation unit. The players have to use the evidence in each episode to unravel the mystery and solve the case. Each episode includes puzzles, evidence, interviews, and more to keep you entertained for hours.
If you love watching murder mystery tv shows then Independence Day Killer will be your new favorite game to play.
If you’re looking for a tv show-like murder mystery game for adults where you have to test your detective skills then check out this unique and spooky game.
4| Vintage Clue VCR Mystery Board Game 1985 VHS Complete
Are you into vintage games? Then check out Smilehood‘s amazing collection like this spooky and fun vintage Clue VCR Mystery Board Game. Don’t worry you can play with it even if you don’t have a VCR anymore since the video is also available on YouTube and you can easily sync it with your game.
If you’re looking for real vintage murder mystery games then this great game is for you.
3| Alice in Wonderland Murder Mystery Game For Adults
Are you ready to experience one of your favorite childhood stories in a completely new way? Then check out this Alice In Wonderland-inspired printable murder mystery dinner party game. It’s great for bigger groups since it can be played by 10 to 14 players and you can even add extra players if needed.
You’ll finally be able to attend one of the famous tea/dinner parties of the Mad Hatter. However, this time you’ll have to solve a murder. Using clues, forensic reports, and even blueberry logs you’ll have to find the killer of Tweedledee.
You’ll also get fun and spooky props to make your gaming experience better including guest invitations, vintage-style wine labels, eat me and drink me tags, and even personalized recipes and menus.
If you love classical stories and want to experience a unique murder mystery game for adults in a whimsical and creepy world then check out this game.
2| At-Home Adult Murder Mystery Game
Do you want to test your deductive skills? Then become a detective in this adult murder mystery game. You will have to work through secret messages, hidden clues, and evidence, all while eliminating or naming suspects, uncovering motives, and bringing justice to the innocent.
It’s one of the few murder mystery games for adults you can play both alone or with friends and family. Each murder mystery box is packed with all kinds of great props such as case files, police notes, newspaper articles, photos, secret messages, hidden clues, and evidence. You’ll also be able to enjoy amazing online websites, text messages, video and voice recording evidence, online hints, solutions, and so much more.
If you love mysteries and looking for challenging murder mystery games for adults then this murder mystery box is for you.
1|1920s Speakeasy Murder Mystery Game For Adults –
Full Murder Mystery Box Kit
Do you love the roaring twenties? Then this brilliant and interactive1920s speakeasy murder mystery game will surely be your new favorite. You’ll get to host a spooky and gorgeous at-home murder mystery party thanks to this unique murder mystery box kit that’ll be printed, organized, and shipped directly to you so you don’t have to worry about anything but enjoying your murder mystery party.
It’s great for smaller and larger groups too since it can be played by 5 to 30 players. You’ll get beautiful props and cards including tips and tricks for party hosts, printable evidence, action cards, award certificates, wine labels, party posters, and voting cards.
If you want to host a spooky and glorious murder mystery game night then go with this 1920’s inspired beauty.
PIN ME for later
Thank you for reading!